ALBUM REVIEW: Carnaval De Luz by U2

U2 remain restless and determined to keep moving forward.
November 18, 2026
2 mins read

U2 doesn’t need this album review. They’ve long moved beyond being an established band and reached the kind of iconic status that makes almost anything they do an event. One either loves U2 or hates U2. There doesn’t seem to be too much of a middle ground when it comes to the band. Some still hold a grudge over the free album that landed in everyone’s iTunes library, while others find the band too cocky, too political, or simply too much. Of course, everything one person dislikes about U2 is often exactly what someone else loves.

But perhaps that’s part of what has kept the band interesting. U2 have never seemed particularly concerned with making themselves universally agreeable, and Carnaval De Luz, their sixteenth studio album and first collection of new studio material in nine years, doesn’t suggest they’re about to start now. Released in the year the band celebrates fifty years together, the record feels like a continuation of a group that has spent its career finding ways to make its familiar musical identity relevant to the moment they’re living in.

There are moments when that connection to the past is particularly apparent. “Street of Dreams” and “The Greatest Show on Earth” feel like spiritual musical sisters to “Where the Streets Have No Name”. The former carries an uplifting sense of possibility, with the familiar combination of guitar and melody that has made U2 so recognisable. The latter draws on that same expansive musical character while turning its attention toward faith, both in another person and in oneself. These songs don’t feel like attempts to recreate an earlier success. They sound like a band returning to the musical language it knows best and finding new things to say with it.

Elsewhere, U2 are happy to move in a different direction. “The Mirror Maker (Rosalía)” in particular has Adam Clayton and Larry Mullen Jr. taking control of the song’s character. The rhythm is slick, seductive, and just a little gritty with a funky groove that feels as though it could have wandered straight out of the 1970s. There’s a wonderfully loose quality to it, and the bass and drums give the track a confidence that makes it difficult not to move along with.

“Silencio” brings a different kind of energy. Its upbeat attack recalls the immediacy of “Vertigo”, while some of its attitude takes me straight back to Achtung Baby. It’s a reminder that U2 have always been capable of embracing a little mischief alongside their more serious concerns. The band knows it doesn’t need to spend every moment being grand or earnest.

The Edge’s guitar is so distinctive that it naturally attracts attention, and Bono’s voice is such a recognisable part of the band’s identity that it’s easy to forget what holds everything together underneath. I’ve always felt that Adam and Larry are an underrated rhythm section and “Can’t Stop Us Now” showcases their tight and subtleness landing like heart beats and haunting footsteps.They provide the foundation that allows The Edge’s guitar to move around them, and the relationship between the three is a significant part of what makes U2 sound like U2.

Featuring the late Dolly Parton, “Torn” is a bittersweet way to close the album. Bono’s voice and Dolly’s unmistakable twangy quiver make for an unexpected but beautiful pairing. Their voices approach the song from different musical traditions, but neither feels out of place. There is a warmth in their contrast that gives the song a particular tenderness, and knowing this is one of her final recorded vocal performances only adds another layer to hearing it.

Fifty years is a remarkable amount of time for any band to remain together, let alone one that has continued to occupy such a visible place in music and popular culture. U2 have provided anthems and soundtracks to decades of personal emotions, political movements, and cultural moments. Carnaval De Luz doesn’t attempt to compete with that history or pretend the band is still trying to prove itself. It simply sounds like U2 continuing to do what they have always done: writing songs with conviction, allowing their musical identity to evolve, and refusing to become comfortable with standing still.

For longtime fans, there’s plenty here that will feel familiar without being a simple return to the past. For newcomers, it’s a pretty good introduction to a band that remains feisty, adventurous, and determined to make itself heard.

Support Us

Subscribe

Get On the List

No spam. No inbox clutter.
Just curated recommendations and the good noise we think deserves your time.

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

You May Enjoy

#listentoVivian