Skip to content
  • Amplified Picks
  • Features
  • Interviews
  • Music
  • News
  • Reviews
  • Watch
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • TikTok
  • YouTube

EP REVIEW: Live at Retrophonics by Caitlin Mahoney

Music Review
Shelia Taylor
March 17, 2025

Caitlin Mahoney’s Live at Retrophonics Studio (March 21st) is a masterful reimagining of her previous work, transforming the polished indie pop tracks of her past into stripped-down heartfelt folk renditions. Recorded live at the legendary Retrophonics Studio in St. Augustine, Florida, the EP captures the raw energy and authenticity of a live performance. The decision to rework these songs into a more organic and folk-driven style is a testament to Caitlin’s versatility and creative spirit.

The EP showcases three reworked tracks: “IDKHTTYN”, “West for a While”, and “Surface Level.” The arrangements are leaner, allowing Caitlin’s poignant lyrics and the emotional pull of the music to take center stage. The live setting amplifies the connection by offering one a sense of being in the room with her and where every note feels spontaneous and real. The intimate nature of the recording process is further elevated by the collaboration with Jacksonville artists Kale That Raps and Howdy. Kale That Raps adds his own fresh verse and harmonies on “Surface Level,” while Howdy’s pedal steel guitar on “West for a While” and “IDKHTTYN” infuses these songs with a sense of yearning, a departure from their more upbeat studio versions.

Live at Retrophonics Studio offers a fresh perspective on Caitlin Mahoney’s evolving sound. The live renditions of these familiar tracks invite one into a more vulnerable and grounded space that showcases her ability to adapt and grow as an artist. It’s a project that not only reflects her musical journey but also honors the local music scene that has inspired her along the way.

Photo by Sydney Whitten

Caitlin Mahoney, Live at Retrophonics Studio

SUPPORT AMPLIFY THE NOISE

THE REVERB LIST 📨

No spam. No inbox clutter. Just curated recommendations and the good noise we think deserves your time.

Read our Privacy Policy for more info.

Thanks for joining The Reverb List. Please check your inbox or spam folder to confirm your subscription.

RECENT NOISE

  • NEW NOISE: “Midnight Coven Crush” by Nova Riot

    NEW NOISE: “Midnight Coven Crush” by Nova Riot

  • QUICK SPIN: “Medicine” by Dela Kay

    QUICK SPIN: “Medicine” by Dela Kay

  • SOUND CHECK: Beautiful Things by Donnie Vie

    SOUND CHECK: Beautiful Things by Donnie Vie

#listentoVIVIAN

You May Enjoy

  • About
  • Contact
  • Legal Bits
  • Support Us
  • What is What

© 2026 Amplify the Noise
We respect and acknowledge the Gadigal people of the Eora Nation as the First Peoples and Traditional Custodians of the land where we operate. We pay our respect to their Elders, past, present and emerging. #AlwaysWasAlwaysWillBe Amplify the Noise may earn a commission from products that are purchased through our site as part of our Affiliate Partnerships with retailers. Ad Choices